What if you cherished yourself, I asked my reflection in the bathroom mirror at school, one day last month. It knocked me out.
I’ve been doing art therapy this fall with a new therapist. During our first session, I drew myself as two distinct bodies, each on one side of a river that flows between them, separates them. The one self sits in peaceful meditation, untroubled, calm, gently smiling, eyes closed, inward-looking but attuned, while the other self gazes at her, lying on her stomach on the river bank, also looking somewhat relaxed, dangling one hand in the river, but she’s frowning, her mind full of muddled thoughts, trying to let them go by placing them onto leaves that are floating by.
What I could express to the therapist was that I longed to be the peaceful self on the other side of the river. She could think clearly. She was untroubled by change. She represented an ever-ness.
The therapist wondered: What if you were the woman on the other side of the river? What would that be like?
I laughed. I couldn’t imagine it. If it tiptoed toward imagining it, I sensed that the muddled self would spoil the peace of that other self simply by attempting to unite them together. It was almost like whatever was contained over there, in that self, would be spoilt by exposure to the rest of me.
It reminded me of a habit I’ve had since childhood. I withhold whatever is most desired from myself. It’s difficult to convince myself to use something that will get used up. A favourite tea, for example, will stay in the box and I’ll brew a different flavour instead. I save things, hoard them. Others eat or consume them instead. Or I tuck away something that I want to enjoy, and never get it out again. I enjoy it by hiding it away. For example, as a child I would hide my Easter candy in my drawer, not sharing it with my brothers, yet never ultimately eating it myself. I could never find an occasion worthy of eating that special candy. Because if I’d eat it, it would be gone. Better to keep it till melted together and spoiled than enjoy it? Strange, right? Interesting. Curious.
Immediately after that vision in the bathroom mirror at school, I went back to the library and scribbled down these words in my notebook:
What if you were the woman on the other side of the river? What would you be like?
How would you treat yourself? What if you treated yourself like a previous vessel? A sacred vessel? An honoured presence?
What if I honoured my presence fully? What if I trusted myself? What if I could just write like it was normal life and not an existential crisis?
Okay, friends. That’s a big what if, but I’m going there. All week I’ve written like it was normal life. It’s been so enjoyable.
xo, Carrie

I agree on – and struggle with – actually enjoying the favorite things, but there is an additional layer in my saving things, which is active enjoyment of the knowledge of possession and availability. Some of that is functional (anticipation is honestly sometimes just as fun as the thing you’re anticipating! … or more fun if you don’t like candy quite as much as you think you would) and some is dysfunctional (hi scarcity mindset and “but what if [nice thing] stops being available?” while knowing that if it *did* stop being available I still would not therefore start *using* it! and this is especially dysfunctional with things that go stale/bad!), but if unwrapping layers, it is *there* in my head and worth reckoning with if it is in yours.
I’ve hit a balance in some things that will get damaged/worn with use by using some and saving some – my absolute favorite pillowcases my mom has embroidered, I am saving so they stay nice and give me a smile whenever I go through the linen closet, but three sets of them are now in regular use so I enjoy them most of the time instead of them being hidden and forgotten about most of the time [I do not clear out the linen closet very often at all]. They’re also just *really nice* pillowcases; vintage high-quality cotton that is smooth but not slick.
Anyway! This may not be a factor with you and saving your favorite tea, but if it is, it’s easier to tackle once you see what it is and can interrogate that holding-off: is this a thing I am deriving enjoyment from anticipation over? Will it spoil? If it does, will that spoil my enjoyment? Can we have our cake and eat it, too, in some way? Or is this exclusively dysfunctional? (there are some forms of emergency preparedness or savoring-saving-for-later that are functional rather than dysfunctional, but… a lot of “only for later” does turn out to be a maladaption.)
Hooray for writing! May your life go well.
I really appreciate all the layers in your thoughtful response, Kate. So much of what you say makes sense to me. Good questions to ask, too.
xo, Carrie
Thank you! xx